Single Pane vs Double Pane Glass: Is It Worth Upgrading an Older Home?
Upgrading to double pane is worth it when the old sashes are worn out or the window is being replaced anyway. If the old wood sashes are sound, sealing the air leaks and adding a tight storm window gives you a second layer of glass and keeps the original window. Swapping only the glass rarely works, because most old sashes are too thin for a sealed double pane unit. Here is how the options compare, and how to choose for your house.
- Window glass work across the DMV
- Free estimates
- Hablamos español
What actually changes between single and double pane
A double pane unit works by trapping a layer of air or gas between two sheets of glass. A storm window does the same thing in a different way: it adds a second layer of glass in front of or behind the old one.
| What you get | Single pane | Single pane plus a storm window | Double pane (sealed unit) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Layers of glass | One | Two, with an air space between the window and the storm | Two, sealed together with a spacer, often gas filled |
| Glass on a winter morning | Cold to the touch, fogs and frosts easily | Warmer inner glass, less fog on the room side | Warmer inner glass, less fog on the room side |
| Low-E coating | Not usual | Available on some storm windows | Common, and easy to add on a new unit |
| Keeps the original window | Yes | Yes | Only if the sash is deep enough, which old sashes rarely are |
| What wears out | Putty and paint, which can be redone | Putty and paint, plus the storm’s seals and hardware | The edge seal; once it fails the unit fogs and is replaced |
Four ways to upgrade an older single pane window
From the least change to the most. Many older houses end up with a mix: the best windows kept, the worst ones replaced.
1. Repair and seal the window
New putty where it has failed, the sash freed and adjusted, weatherstripping where the sash meets the frame. It keeps the window and stops most drafts. How putty is redone: cracked or missing glazing putty.
2. Add a storm window
An exterior or interior storm adds the second layer of glass. Interior storms leave the outside of the house unchanged, which matters on older homes.
3. New insulated sash in the old frame
Where the frame is sound but the sash is worn out, a new sash with double pane glass can go into the existing frame and trim.
4. A new window
When the frame is rotted or the window cannot be repaired. We cover this on window replacement.
Can double pane glass go into an old sash?
Usually not. The glass in an old wood sash sits in a shallow groove called the rabbet, made for one thin pane. A sealed double pane unit is much thicker, so it will not fit without cutting the sash, and an old sash is often too slim to cut safely.
Some newer single pane sashes, and some metal ones, do have room. We check the depth of the rabbet at the free estimate and tell you plainly whether a unit fits. Window with grids? See can you replace one pane in a window with grids. If the pane is simply broken and you want to keep the window as it is, that is single pane glass replacement.
Where the cold really comes from in an old window
On a windy day, hold your hand near the edges of an old sash, then near the middle of the glass. The edges usually feel worse. A lot of the cold in an older window is air getting in around the sash, the meeting rail and the frame, and new glass does nothing about that.
That is why the first step is to stop the air leaks, then decide about the glass. The National Park Service’s guidance on weatherizing historic windows says adding storm windows can improve the thermal efficiency of any window, old or new.
If you can feel the air moving, start with drafty window repair. If the problem is water on the glass on winter mornings, read condensation on the inside of windows first.
Upgrade or keep: how to decide
Upgrading to double pane makes sense when
- The sashes are rotted, loose or past repair
- The window is being replaced anyway, for a remodel or an addition
- You want low-E glass to cut heat from a sunny wall
- Storm windows are not practical, for example on casements or tall picture windows
- Nobody in the house wants to take storms on and off or maintain old putty
Keeping the single pane makes sense when
- The sashes and frames are sound and only the putty and paint are tired
- The house is historic or the original windows are part of its character
- The old glass has the wavy look you want to keep
- A storm window can go over it, inside or out
- You only have one or two drafty windows, not a whole house
Already have double pane windows that have fogged up? That is a different question: see how long double pane windows last and double pane glass replacement. Weighing a coating as well? See is low-E glass worth it.
What we look at on a visit
We check each window rather than giving one answer for the whole house: the sash, the putty, the rabbet depth and the frame. Then we tell you which windows to keep and seal, which take new glass, and which are worth replacing. All our window glass services are on window glass repair.
- A photo of each window type in the house, inside and out
- A close photo of the glass edge where it meets the wood
- Whether there are storm windows now, and whether they still close tight
- Which rooms feel cold or drafty
Single pane vs double pane questions
More questions? Read fixing a drafty window without replacing it and why a window won’t stay open, plus window permits in Virginia, historic districts and work without a permit, browse our glass repair FAQ or contact us.
Is it worth replacing single pane windows with double pane?
It is worth it when the old sashes are worn out or the windows are being replaced anyway. If the sashes are sound, sealing the air leaks and adding a storm window keeps the original window and still gives you a second layer of glass.
Are storm windows as good as double pane windows?
They are not the same. A sealed double pane unit needs no seasonal care, while a storm window has its own seals and hardware to look after. But a tight storm over a sound, well sealed window adds a second layer of glass and an air space, which is a real improvement over single glass alone.
Why are single pane windows so cold in winter?
One sheet of glass lets the room’s heat pass through easily, so the inner surface gets cold and fogs. Older windows also leak air around the sash and frame, which often feels worse than the glass itself.
Should I keep the original windows in an older home?
Keep them if the sashes and frames are sound, especially on a historic house. Repair the putty and paint, seal the air leaks and add storms. Replace the ones that are rotted or cannot be repaired.
What is the cheapest way to make a single pane window warmer?
Stop the air leaks first: fix failed putty, free and adjust the sash, and add weatherstripping where it meets the frame. After that, a storm window adds the second layer of glass.
Not sure what your windows need?
Send photos of your windows, or call (202) 600-6220 for a free estimate.